Ice Cream

Vanilla, Chocolate or Swirl? Cake or Waffle Cone? How about a Shake? Toppings? We have tons of those! Pizza Shop not only offers the standard soft serve ice cream fare, but we took it to the next level with chef inspired sundaes and an ever changing assortment of Jane’s Ice Cream – made right here in the Hudson Valley. Stop by for a scoop (or two) and bring the kiddos on Sundae Monday’s when we give kids FREE sundaes with every purchase of $20 or more!


Pizza & Beer… Any Questions? Pizza Shop offers Domestic & Imported Bottles as well as Stella Artois on tap. Our other taps are filled with killer local brews like the ones our friends up the street produce at Newburgh Brewing Company.


Pizza Shop currently has 10 wines by the glass or bottle. Our wines were selected by our own wine aficionado Nick Citera, who has earned the Wine Spectator’s Award of Excellence for 17 Years at our sister restaurant, Cosimo’s On Union. The wines range in price from $6-$10 a glass and you’ll be sure to find the perfect pairing for everything on our menu!